Emancipatory narrativity in our turbulent era

This article is about so-called non-fictional narratives, which are said to provide compelling access to the diversity of realities, experiences and perspectives. Promising, but there are also contemporary pitfalls. However, an analysis that goes beyond a simple understanding of narrativity could lead to a retelling that can be politico-ethically transformative for, for example, institutional care. The presence theory offers a hopeful starting point.

From being heuristically valuable for epistemic justice, to being misleading, to becoming undesirable determining factors—narratives cover nowadays the entire spectrum. The presence approach, in short, develops a relational and attentive care practice whereby the committed professional can truly connect with the care recipient’s lived experience.

A symposium of the Presence Foundation, held in 2024 in Utrecht (The Netherlands), was a dynamic event celebrating the profound impact of presence and narrativity in professional practices. In the first part of this article we give as main point an impression of the presentation of professor Andries Baart ((1)) about presence theory and the critical role of storytelling in the context of this approach.

Inspired by his arguments, in the second part of this article we then seek to examine the current prominence of individual expressions, emancipatory narratives and performances within a politico-ethical context in turbulent times. How do apocalyptic thinking, short-term policies and alienation fit into this picture? What has become of the emancipatory ambition of the individual long-term and bottom-up (life) narrative of the vulnerable?

Part I: ‘A Strong Story’, an impression

Professor Andries Baart delivered a politico-ethical engaged narrative of presence theory with his keynote presentation “A Strong Story” ((2)). Baart focused on the specific implications for an ethical significance of narrativity and its importance within the presence approach. His own engagement with narratives—ranging from admiration to a finally sharp, critical analysis of this important phenomenon—served as the foundation for his argument regarding retelling institutional care as a path to significant transformational processes.

The emancipatory narrative of uniqueness

During the academic career of Andries Baart, a turning point occurred where a philosophical approach to narrativity was concerned. For a long time, it seemed obvious to consider personal, unique stories mainly as individualistic expressions, with as specific features their own, not quite fathomable meaning. These expressions set their own centers of attention, being unconsciously embedded in a certain cultural background. Also part of the classical perspective on narrativity is that the perception and proper attitude of the Other are indispensable, in order to understand (‘zu verstehen’) the story in an attentive, intersubjective process between narrator and perceiver.

The narrator and his perception, signification and own truth become apparent. If her of his life and story have been underappreciated until now, this is particularly worth noting. Thus considered, in classical conceptualization, one’s own narration and its truthful perception has a purely emancipatory thrust. In this reading, a ‘healing’ (Baart) effect could be hidden in the act of telling.

The instrumental use of storytelling

But over the years, upon closer examination, Baart’s view of narrativity took a significant turn. The instrumental use of narratives of all kind can be frequently traced, for instance in situations where populism has appeal, or misleading discourses prevail. Narratives are not armed against outside influences; thus the individualistic frame does not suffice. Baart therefore argues for narrativity to be critically considered and thoroughly examined as possible objects of power influences. These influences on individual narrative expressions should be analyzed by way of specification of the various inherent elements which constitute the narrative. They can hardly be distinguished from each other, in an initially opaque interplay of factors.

Alienation and expropriation

Elements such as one’s own inner dialogue, discourses and the co-determining (institutional) context in which the story can be told, flow into each other. “Alienation” and “expropriation” ((3 )) are phenomena that can be gradually decoded during the analysis, which Baart proposes.

To this end, Baart locates several ‘story-places’ ((4)), which offer, each time from inherently different positions, an opportunity to ‘story’ about experiences with the presence approach within care institutions. The diversity of experiences and stories in care systems is wide given the variety of positions within this field. The following sources of narratives are addressed: the care recipient as a starting point, the reflecting caregiver, a discourse analysis regarding power influences—in order to detect misappropriation—and additionally a clear narrative statement of accountability. These sources of knowledge lead to a retelling at the meso-level, such as at the policy level, and finally to narrative theorizing.

Epistemic justice and institutional transformation

This systematization is inherently critical of the individualistic content of narrativity and focuses on deeper questioning and interpretation: which story is told each time by whom, to what end and at which position, taking into account internalized power influences (such as discourses). It is a retelling that comes about in a complex process and remedies ‘epistemic injustice’ ((5)). In this framework, the presence approach can thus facilitate a compelling, genuine reinterpretation of care that takes into account the individual, the organizational and the political dimensions. Baart termed such a complex, comprehensive analysis an ‘institutional retelling’ ((6)).

It makes the experience obtained with the presence approach at various levels applicable to a workable transformation of institutions/care organizations. Analysis and awareness of internalizing power effects through narrative theorizing can counter ‘alienation ‘and ‘expropriation’. In this way, the stories become stronger and stronger, they imply ‘criticism and strong engagement’ ((7)) in order to get closer (together) to the truth about good care.

Identifying undiscovered relational connections

The connection between the various story-places becomes explicit in the systematization mentioned above. Thus, through this retelling, the presence approach can also identify relational connections within all sections of a care institution. Baart concludes that presence theory not only provides space for stories, but at the same time is itself a retelling that can be politico-ethical.

Baart concludes his keynote with a hopeful outlook on transformative processes, which are so sorely needed in today’s world. His analytic storyline took us on a journey through both an individual bottom-up experience and broader perspectives on dynamics that were previously hidden.

Manifestations of authenticity, power, and discourse can thus be intertwined without our noticing. The fact that alienation arises from this is an interpretation that warrants special attention. Doesn’t presence theory itself tell us that good care and persistent alienation are incompatible? We believe the process of alienation is worth further investigation in the context of the current turbulent era.

Part II : Editorial reflections

In this second part of our essay we concentrate on the pitfalls of the ‘unique story’ in the current era. We therefore now leave the presentation of Andries Baart and take it as a reference point that leads us to a reflection on alienation in the contemporary late-modern Western context. To this end, we draw on the various current implications of storytelling and performance. Both forms of expression have received significant attention, particularly in the real world of our turbulent late-modern age.

In theory, within the thinking of postmodernity and thus pluralism, the individuality and authenticity of a personal story have become part of an inherent emancipatory and ethical perspective. In care ethics in particular, there is a strong emphasis on intersubjectivity and epistemic justice.

But why for instance has ‘storytelling’ in our current, often confusing times, also transformed into a key element in commercial advertising strategies? What highlights the emancipatory character of the narrative approach on the one side and its remarkable shortcomings on the other? For further investigation, we first take a brief overview of the philosophical context, including the implications that arise from the historical context. We also refer to several authors in our reflection.

Between great universal stories and uniqueness

Narrativity as a philosophical concept positions itself amid postmodernity and then late modernity ((8)) The rise of modernity had emphasized human rationality (see also Rene Descartes), and thence universally applicable ideas, principles and scientific knowledge. Consequently, man was characterized as a reflexive and autonomously, detached acting subject. Theory-building and, by extension, ideologies (sometimes near-religious, salvation-oriented or idealistic) slowly made their way into Western societies.

In postmodernity, these “great—universal—narratives” were once again abandoned, according to Jean-Francois Lyotard ((9)). The upcoming more-perspectivity was in increasingly more approaches (see care ethics) accompanied by the de-centering of the subject previously considered fully autonomous. Subject-being no longer constituted itself simply by being as (autonomously) detached as possible from the environment.

In its place came the relating to the individually imminent context, and consequently the uniqueness that arises from it against the background of an increasingly pluralistic society. One’s own (life) story lends itself to the expression of nowadays welcome uniqueness. It is a form of expression that ideally can capture the complexity and ambiguity of one’s own relations with the environment without having to commit to a “big story either to theories/ideologies” ((10)) and their dominating logic.

The moral charge of contextual narrativity

Through one’s own so-called ‘little (life)story’ one can truly be known by the ‘Other’, provided that the ‘little (life)story’ is actually lived through and thus reflects one’s own experiences. ‘Lived—context-dependent—life’ and thus its unique experience came into the focus of also qualitative (phenomenological) science research, in order to do justice to the plurality of practices and to the perception of the otherness of ‘the Other’.

This was for instance clearly articulated by Paul Ricoeur ((11)). He unfolds his concept of narrative identity according to his explicit ontology of man as a “narrative” and relational being. Identity forms over a lifetime in the dialectic between fixed personality traits and the narrative interpretation humans give to what they encounter in changing circumstances and encountering ‘the Other’.

Ricoeur’s hermeneutic concept also points out that individual (small) life stories represent the past, the present (the moment of interpretation of the past) and the future (the guiding meaning). Seen in this light, interpretation and going through all the stages of life are the core concepts. In this way, narrative identity is an ontological concept that also reveals vulnerabilities and tragedy, which are key concerns of care ethics (see also Jeannet van de Kamp’s contributions on this website). Ricoeur’s studies illustrate once again that the narrative concept is based on the value of ongoing long-term individual experience in practice (in life).

This is where the potential moral charge of valuing narrativity—in the non-fictional sense—emerges: The perception of individual narratives takes into account the uniqueness of the subject and, at the same time, the contextual and relational surrounding in which the subject actually exists. As a result, narrativity is a kind of powerful expression and can provide, more than alienation, an emancipatory impetus, in case it is understood as an emphasis on the diversity of human constitutions and individual lived-through long-term perspectives.

The political perspective

In postmodern feminist philosophy, as is known in care ethics, the intra-personal dimensions take on also political significance. The physical, emotional, gendered, embodied and relational dimension was revalued and correlated with the undesirable subordination of one’s own position in society. Feminists no longer wanted to be objects defined by a prevailing view, but rather active subjects. This emancipatory statement brought the well-known, at the beginning powerful, emancipatory feminist movement along.

Foucault ((12)), in the same era, asked in his inquiry what ‘being a subject’ could implicate: is the subject not—unnoticed— too vulnerable in the face of discourses, consisting of collective and ‘grand’ narratives, that claim to be objective and morally ambitious (as to promote abstract ‘values’)? All discourses, in fact, constitute a power factor, often due to economic conditions. Thus, Foucault suspects the claim of being ‘a subject’.

The analysis of the conditions of the powerful, invisible effects of discourses and narratives, and then also of the small stories, is essential. This theory of power fosters greater skepticism toward the discursive call for relationality and connection. Consequently, no broad movement emerged from this. It was intended to break through an illusory world and also through alienation that could go with the illusion…

Late modernity, narrativity and alienation

Late modern discourses revolve, among other things, around the importance of uniqueness, relationality, authenticity and subjectivity, or, in other words, the ‘soft skills’. The relevance of these skills would also be partially endorsed by feminism and, consequently, care ethics. However, there is, according to Foucault, a pitfall. For instance as soon as businesslike thinking (as a kind of ‘underlying grand narrative’) creeps unnoticed into all capillaries of society. Whilst, at the same time, an occurring (fear of) societal decline or apocalyptic thinking is affecting individual lives. This is outlined below:

The associated power mechanism promotes an ambiguous process. On the one hand, it is uniqueness, which is openly valued in order to make a participatory contribution, for instance to labor reorganization processes from ‘one’s own, authentic and therefore vulnerable bottom-up-perspective’. On the other hand, it is precisely this ‘own story’ that has to be unconsciously ‘sold’ to the ‘big underlying story’: namely a kind of thinking which aims at economic struggle for survival on micro-, meso- and macro level.

Not only in the Netherlands, for example, the urgent call for future-proofing is heard in all possible professional situations. In a remarkable paradoxical process, this collective narrative leads to short-term policy decisions regarding innovation and ongoing changes in the context of this struggle. In this dynamic, real experience gets alienated. There is, however, no need to question the good intentions of all those involved.

Experience-based knowledge on the edge

Experience-based knowledge is nowadays promoted as a valuable source of knowledge. That refers to practical professional wisdom that emerges from ‘bottom-up’ experience through longtime professional practice. Consequently men strive for bottom-up organized care-organizations with flat hierarchies in a value-driven work environment. But in fact it cannot win it from the above mentioned ongoing drive to innovate in care systems (in the Netherlands). This generates systems that turn into an economic race of the “the best solution-product”, embodied in programs that are ultimately detached from real-world practice, yet they are,  paradoxically, so-called “practice-oriented.”

It remains unclear then, to what extent the unique, practice-based “experienced perspective” still is containing genuine lived elements, without a conscious awareness of the aforementioned dynamic. The perception of ‘the Other’ is then distorted without being noticed—a kind of alienation in the vein of Baart—or, in the reading of Foucault, a illusionary world emerges, with the values of authenticity, connection, and collaboration serving as its banner. But in practice, the proof becomes the property of alienation.

Counter-stories?

Conceptually, for instance Chantal Mouffe ((13)) emphasizes the importance of artistic ‘counter-stories’ in public space, which can question the dominant order. Against the backdrop of the analysis mentioned above, there is still a risk that concepts of narrative participation will become a popular but ultimately illusory formula within the discursive, innovative ambition of ‘participation’—and thus a deception for the participants.

Given this political dimension, the practical value and strength of the concept of narrativity could be re-evaluated in the context of the phenomena mentioned above. If transformed into the late modern reading of storytelling and artistic performance, pitfalls get a chance. Could for instance the contemporary care ethical turn to esthetic and performance be vulnerable to such a pitfall? One example is the risk it could lead to alienation, when this approach mainly stresses the—in this sense also narrative—elements of subjective experience, uniqueness, embodiment (performance) and finally authenticity.

Conclusion

Finally, how powerful narrativity could be, can thus not be conclusively weighed here. Without the attention to underlying power dynamics, all stories and performances got weakened anyway. Concerning good care in (health-)care institutions, Baart warns us in his impressive presentation to be aware of alienation, despite the apparent ‘authenticity’ of narratives through the internalization of power dynamics. He clarifies that the presence approach is viewed as a ‘grand retelling’. The retelling confronts and contrasts—in a complex, narrative, analytical, and relational manner—the logic of the underlying systems thinking within healthcare institutions. In this way it is indeed a powerful ‘retelling’, as a path to a counter-story regarding alienation.


Notes
((1)) Prof. Dr. Andries Baart (born 1952) is a Dutch sociologist, philosopher, and practical theologian best known as the founder of Presence Theory (presentie theorie), and a leading figure in the Dutch ethics of care movement. [In 2004, he co-founded the Presence Foundation (Stichting Presentie) to translate his research into practical frameworks for healthcare, social work, and education.]
((2)) https://www.presentie.nl/uploads/23een-sterk-verhaal-aj-baart-2024.pdf
((3)) ibid.
((4)) ibid.
((5)) ibid.
((6)) ibid.
((7)) ibid.
((8)) Banning, H., Banning-Mul, M (2010). Narratieve begeleidingskunde. Nelissen: Soest
((9)) ibid.
((10)) ibid.
((11)) Ricoeur, P. (1994). Oneself as Another. University of Chicago Press: Chicago
((12)) Foucault, M. (1997). Ethics. Subjectivity and truth. The New Press: New York
((13) Mouffe, C. (2008). https://ps.wdka.nl/digitalcraft/images/8/86/Art_and_Democracy_-_Chantal_Mouffe.pdf

For further reading on Presence Theory:
Baart, A, Timmermanm,G (2024): Relational Caring and Presence Theory in Health Care and Social Work: A Care-Ethical Perspective. Policy Press: Bristol

 

About the author: Silke Jacobi

Silke Jacobi

Silke Jacobi had her master’s degree in the Ethics of Care at the University of Humanistic Studies (Utrecht) in 2019. In her master thesis she investigated 'late modern', invisible power dynamics with seemingly subject-oriented, but equally neoliberal subtitles: this double-tingled, turbulent context influences the morally and critically concerned care-workers and has impact of institutional questions. Since 1990 she explores as a social worker the changes of the complex (institutional) care-praxis also from an inside-perspective. In addition, she worked as a supervisor for upcoming social workers at a university of applied sciences. The broad political-ethical context for care-ethical issues is one of her concerns.